Benny Montanaro’s

Building upon the original Benedito persona, Montanaro’s depicts Benny’s love of the outdoors. A giant slice of pizza it is, then back out to fishing and hiking you go. We like to imagine this would be Benny’s perfect afternoon. Montanaro means “mountain” in Italian, and that’s fitting, because Wyoming is home to the second highest mountain ranges in the United States.

We opened in the city of Casper in November of 2021 and have been cranking out our huge slices and giant 28” pies to Casperian’s ever since. Benny Montanaro’s is located at 327 Thelma Drive, in the Plaza East Shopping Mall. Benny guarantees you won’t be hungry when you leave.

Name*
First Last
Email*
Phone
Shop to Contact*
Your Message*

Directions

327 Thelma Dr.
Casper, Wyoming 82609

Pick-Up or Delivery Options

Pick-Up or Delivery from Benny's
DoorDash
UberEats
Windy City Delivery

Hours

Monday 11am - 8pm
Tuesday 11am - 8pm
Wednesday 11am - 8pm
Thursday 11am - 8pm
Friday 11am - 12am
Saturday 11am - 12am
Sunday 11am - 8pm

Pizza Rules Everything Around Me #bennys #getthemoney #dolladollabillsyall
@emsirheats

Drop Day with June Specials! BBQ Chicken and the Garden State (spinach/ricotta/garlic) #wait #isitjune #whatyearisit

Graduation may be virtual but the pizza is still real. Free slice for all grads in cap and gown! #classof2020 @abbsvoyt

To all the mothers, you deserve a night alone with a whole pizza #mothersday #heymama @ericagenevra

Feeding the troops on the front lines #notallheroeswearcapes @breannagraybill

Stay right there. Online ordering now available on our website www.bennys.pizza

Mankind's gotta eat. Come stock up on pizza, we won't touch you #pizza #restaurants #nocontact

Congrats @centrotacobar on your grand opening in the Big Als space! Best logo in town. See yall after as usual... #downtown #blacksburg #frozenmargarita #boilinghotpizza

Any excuse is a good excuse for #pizza. #nationalpizzaday #bennys @annetaylorhough

When you want to share with your friends... #pizzaunites #bennys

First time at Benny's: documented.
#downtown #VT #pizza #bennys
@hannah.credno

Only one way to start the spring semester #hokiesbasketball #bennys #maybeclass

Happy Caturday! Circa 2013 @alexafalse

With snow comes sweaters, hot pizza, and a solid Cheerwine ad @drinkcheerwine #bennys @graacecaro

Our new Miss America 2020, circa 2016. Congrats @camilleschrier !!!

#bennyspizza

Benny Montanaro’s

Specialty Toppings

Wild Bill

Three Little Pigs

Regulars

Cheese

Pepperoni

Sliced Italian Sausage

Garlic Mushroom

Not Pizza

Chips $2

Topping Suggestion Box

Directions

Pick-Up or Delivery Options

Hours